Buying a tuba or a euphonium is always an important decision that has to be thoughtfully taken.The price of these instruments is high, and, for that, we must be extremely cautious when it comes to investing our money in them.
In this post I willl give you some pieces of advice that will help decide what instruments to choose.
I alays try not talk about brands or trademarks to my students or their families, instead I rather refer to differents types of quality.
From my poin of view, deciding between one instrument an another depends on its intended purpose. Once its use and quality are clear, we will look for the brand that best meets our needs.
What instrument should I buy?
To answer this question, we first have to take into consideration the
level of the musician who is going to play this tuba or euphonium. The decision
will be different depending on whether the person is a
professional musician, an
amateur player, or a
beginner, intermediate or advance student.On the other hand, if the instrument is going to be played in a brass band or other music groups, we have to consider other aspects that might affect the final decision.
1º - Beginners or amateur musicians.
There are two main options for students at elementary levels or amateur musicians who are just beginning their training.
1st - Buying a low/medium-quality instrument:The price ranges between
€600 and €900 for
euphonium and
€3.000 and €4.000 for
tubas. These instruments are
perfect for beginners, since they will last for 4 or 5 years, which is enough time to determine if the student is happy with the instrument and wants to continue his/her training.
If the students wants to quit, it´s a small investment and the instrument can be easily resold to a new student, which means that it´s possible to recover part of the original investment.
Nowadays all the brands manufacture instruments in various qualities, which make the choice much easier.
Below I mention some brans and models:
Euphonium:
- Thomann 902 or 904: These are very innovative models that have surprised us, providing quality at a reasonable price. Here you can read an analysis of the Thomann EP 902 Superior
3/4 Tuba:
4/4 tuba:
2nd - Buying a high-quality instrument:
A high-quality instrument has to be
appropriate for it´s
professional practice. If the student wants to continue his/her musical training, this is the
best option - as long as the family can afford it.
On the other hand, it´s high quality will make it easier to sell and to recover a big part of the investment.
Medium-quality instruments are
more difficults to sell on the
second-hand market, although they normally
work well in
brass bands or
amateurs music groups.
Euphonium: (always compensating sistem)
Tuba:
- Miraphone - 85 B / 86 A / 88.
- Thomann Grand Fifty S - C Tuba.
2º - Professional training and higher education.
It´s highly recommended that
students in the last year of their intermediate training or already in
higher education courses buy a
high-quality instrument.
Prices range between
€4.000 and
€6.000 for
euphoniums and between
€6.000 and
€14.000 for
tubas.
Buying a hight-quality instruments entails a full
commitment to the study (5-6 hours per day), which will lead to
professional dedication.An important factor that should be taken into account when buying a high-quality instruments is a that, if
everything goes well, we
won´t have to replace it with a new one. In other words, we are buying an instrumente that can
last us for the rest of our musical career.
Buying a high-quality instrument entails studying for 5-6 hours per day.
- Miraphone M5050 Ambassador.
F Tubas:
- B&S 56 AFT-L / Perantuchi 5099 / JBL classic 3100 / MRF-F
- Miraphone Belcanto-Solo F 381 C / F 381 F
- Miraphone Firebird F281C / F281B
- Miraphone Petruschka F1281
Eb Tubas:
- Besson - BE 177 (Estudent)
- Besson - BE 984 (Professional)
- Miraphone Ambassador EEB M 7000 / 7050
- Walternirschl ES- tuba Modell MWN 4 / MWN 3
C Tubas:
- Hirsbrunner CC HBS 290 y 390 (4/4) / HBS 293 (5/4)
- Walternirschl C Tuba MWN 7 / MWN 8
- Miraphone 90 (5/4) / 291 (5/4)
Bb Tubas: Currently this tipe of instruments is not very common in Spain, where we traditionally play the tuba in C. However,
if we intend to get a job in other
European countries, especially in
Germany and Austria, playing in
Bb will make things easier.
3º - Amateur musicians:
There are
plenty of amateur musicians that have their own instrument because they
are passionate about tuba or euphoniums.
My advice for these musicians is to
buy an instrument with the highest possible quality, so it
will motivate them and get them to devote more time to practicing.
Therefore, my recommendation is the same as for students in the last years of their
intermediate training or starting in higher education courses.
4ª Music Bands:
Wind bands and
brass bands play an essential role
in teaching and promoting music in our contries, why they deserve their own section in this post.
These music groups are formed by
people of different ages and with different training, entailing very diverse needs.
Therefore, in order for these music groups to be successful it is very importan that they have the
appropriate materials to face the
different situations that might arise.
Ideally, they would have
two types of instruments:
A - Low/medium-quality and small-size instruments: The band would provide these instruments to the new students that want to learn how to play them, with the objetive of
attracting new members and contributing to childres´ early development.
Furthermore,
families could borrow these instruments since little scratches or bumps due to daily use wouldn´t be very important.
The
most recommendable sizes for
tubas are compact
3/4 or 4/4. Ideally, music bands should have
2 or 3 euphoniums and
1 or 2 tubas to ensure that both
sections of the band are always covered.
Euphoniums:
Tubas:
An important aspect to consider is that
tubas and
euphoniums intended for bands
needs straps and a clamp-on lyre so they can be played
in parades and processions.B- High-quality and medium-size instruments: With these instruments we will allow children who started with 3/4 tubas
to play higher-quality instruments when they are between 14 or 16 years old. They will be able to play bigger instruments in a short time, and it will encourage them to continue practicing.
On the other hand, these instruments
also allow adults who want to play music as
a hobby to master an instrument that is very useful in
parades and processions, common events among music bands.
Euphonium:
Tuba:
- B&S - 4097- L (PT20) / PT 6 (5/4)
- Miraphone CC 86 A / 86 B / 88 (4/4) / 90 B (5/4) /291 B (5/4)
5º - Instruments made of plastic.
In recent times
new tubas and euphonium made of plactic came onto the market.
They offer
multiple benefits because of their
light weight, which makes them
ideal for long parades.
They are also available in very
bright colours, whitch make them
very attractive for young children and
helps to promote these instruments.
Another
strong plus is thay they are
cheaper, around
€400 for a euphonium and
€1.000 for a tuba.
Amazon offers
very competitive prices for both instruments from the brand
PlayLite:
#-1#
#-2#
#-3#
Here you can read a
ANALYSIS OF THE TUBA MADE OF PLASTIC
FINAL REMARKS
Where to buy them: Every country has many shops with a wide variety of instruments and prices in their catalogues. Most of them work with high-quality instruments and offer a very professional service.
It is highly recommended that
the shop has instruments for you to try, as well as
maintenance and repair service.How to buy them: Once you have chosen the instrument you are interested in, it is important to consider the aspects listed below before actually buying it.
- Seek expert advice and, if in doubt, get a second opinion, specially if you are considering a high-quality instrument. You can seek expert advice from conservatorie teachers and orchestra musicians, among others.
- Compare prices in different shops. Ideally, you should compare the price of the same instruments, which normally does not vay much, but you might eventually find an interesting offer.
- Once you have chosen the instrument, the best hing would be to try differents models or request a trial period. I also recommend that a professional tests the instrument.
The different
brands I have mentioned in this post are
just suggestions, there are plenty of models that might be equally interesting.
My recommendation is that you obtain as much information as you need and that you check that characteristics of the instruments meet your needs.
This post has been written in collaboration with
"Alfonso Mollá Castells",
euphonium professor at the Conservatorio Superior de Música de Asturias.(Higher Education Conservatorie of Asturias, Spain)
In the section
ANALYSIS of this blog, you can find some test of tubas an euphoniums.